News Stories
Bentley & More LLP achieves $44,100,000 binding arbitration award on behalf of an injured worker
On February 27, 2019, Keith More of Bentley & More LLP in Newport Beach, achieved a $44,100,000 binding arbitration award per the labor union contract on behalf of his client Erick Gonzalez, a worker injured in November 2014 when he fell 24-25 feet while working as a connector building a multistory commercial building. Mr. Gonzalez was landing steel decking bundles onto iron cross beams at the building project when he tripped over a black banding strap and fell to the ground below. Mr. Gonzalez was immediately hospitalized, underwent spinal surgery, and was separated from his family for years while he received treatment. Even to this day, Mr. Gonzalez remains quadriplegic with 100% permanent disability.
Bentley & More LLP litigated both the third-party personal injury case and the worker’s compensation matter on Mr. Gonzalez’s behalf. After a confidential settlement in the third-party case, reached by Greg Bentley and Keith More, Mr. Gonzalez’s employer (Herrick Corporation) and its insurer (Arch Insurance Company) sought a credit in the worker’s compensation case—which would have eliminated Mr. Gonzalez’s right to receive benefits until the amount of credit was reached—of more than $2,000,000. But credits are not available to the employer until it has paid its proportionate share of liability – its percentage of fault multiplied by the injured worker’s total tort damages.
Bentley & More LLP and Keith More fought tirelessly against the employer’s petition for credit, based on Herrick’s extensive fault for the accident, including Mr. Gonzalez’s supervisors knowing about the bands, knowing they were a tripping hazard, and only marking them with orange spray paint after Mr. Gonzalez suffered his devastating fall. Mr. More’s efforts resulted in a binding arbitration with Herrick and its insurer, where the arbitrator found that Herrick Corporation was 60% at fault for Mr. Gonzalez’s injuries, and found his tort damages totaled more than $73,000,000. Applying Herrick’s percentage of fault, the binding arbitration thus found that Herrick and its insurer were not entitled to a single dollar of credit until they had paid benefits exceeding $44,100,000.
“We are thrilled that the arbitrator saw this petition for credit for what it was – a sham by Herrick and its insurer to avoid paying benefits,” said attorney Keith More. “Under this binding award, Erick will be entitled to receive the benefits he deserves, and full treatment for his injuries for the rest of his life. ”
The case name is Erick Gonzalez v. Herrick Corporation, et al., Ironworkers Collectively Bargained Workers Compensation Program Case No. IWADR 00572.
Read MoreIs the County Responsible for Pothole Damage?
Are Personal Injury Settlements Community Property?
Can I Claim Personal Injury If I Was at Fault?
Do Car Seats Expire?
Who is Eligible for Death Benefits?
When a loved one dies, family may not think of money first. However, depending on the circumstances, the dissemination of death benefits may help alleviate funeral expenses or even provide for family members left behind. Are you informed regarding your eligibility for death benefits?
What Death Benefits Are Available?
Although the period immediately after a death is a trying time, it is often the best time to do your research regarding death benefits – once the completed death certificate is in your hand, you should begin applications. In most cases, funeral directors can ask surviving families about any death benefits, as well as provide guidance regarding applications. Consider whether your loved one may have been eligible for any of these benefits:
- Life insurance survivor’s benefits
- Social Security benefits
- Workers’ compensation benefits
- Veterans’ benefits
- Pension or retirement benefits
While life insurance survivor’s benefits, veterans’ benefits, and pension and retirement benefits are specific to the deceased person’s life insurance plan and place of employment, workers’ comp and Social Security benefits follow a relatively strict set of rules.
Workers’ Compensation Benefits
If your loved one died as the result of a work-related illness or injury, you may be able to collect California workers’ comp death benefits. In order to collect benefits, you must be financially dependent on the deceased and a close member of his or her family. Recipients can include:
- Spouses
- Children, stepchildren, and adopted children
- Grandchildren
- Parents or parents-in-law
- Grandparents
- Aunts, uncles, nieces, and nephews
However, each recipient must depend on the deceased for financial survival. Minor children, disabled children of any age, and spouses earning less than $30,000 per year are automatically 100% dependent. In the event multiple dependents exist, the state will divide benefits between them based on level of dependency.
In order to file a workers’ comp death benefit claim, you must prove your financial dependence on the deceased. You must file claims within a year of the death, and no more than 240 weeks from the date of the original injury.
Social Security Benefits
Social Security distributes two, distinct benefits – the death benefit, and survivor benefits.
The Social Security death benefit is a one-time, $255 payment which can only go to a surviving spouse or child. Separated spouses may still claim eligibility for the benefit if they were living with the deceased at the time of death or were eligible for survivor’s benefits on the deceased person’s work record. SSA declares children eligible in the absence of an eligible spouse, but any children must be eligible for benefits – a minor, an unmarried 18- or 19-year-old in high school, or a disabled, unmarried adult.
Social Security calculates survivor benefits based on the deceased person’s work history – workers earning at least $5,440 per year have earned all four of the work credits possible in a given year. Typically, a worker must earn 40 work credits for Social Security benefits, though the number decreases for younger workers.
Family members most often eligible for survivor’s benefits are:
- Widows aged 60 or older, including some divorced spouses and disabled widows 50 or older
- Widows at any age caring for the deceased individual’s children 16 and under, or disabled children
- Unmarried, minor children or children aged 18 and 19 if they enroll in high school
- Unmarried, disabled children of any age so long as the disability was present before age 22
- Stepchildren, grandchildren, or adopted children under certain circumstances
- Dependent parents under certain circumstances
For both death and survivor’s benefits, you must notify SSA of the death. Most funeral homes will report the death if supplied with the deceased person’s Social Security number. Alternatively, you can call SSA yourself or visit the nearest SSA office in person. For questions about your specific case, reach out to our Orange County injury lawyers at Bentley & More, LLP for a free consultation!
Read More